|
Perception refers to your awareness and understanding of things. People behave as though their perceptions are reality, but in truth we usually perceive an incomplete and often somewhat inaccurate picture of events around us. The perception of a given event varies from person to person and is influenced by many factors (Chang, 1996; Lee, Hallahan, & Herzog, 1996). Consider the following example: people walking by a professor and student who are having a serious discussion. One student observer cringes and thinks, "Oh, she is really getting nailed by that professor! I wonder what she did wrong." A second student envies the involvement he perceives to be taking place and thinks, "I wish I could get into meaningful discussions with my professors. They never even give me the time of day!"
Children rarely question the veracity of their perceptions. As people get older, they begin to understand that they may misunderstand. It is a sign of maturity to question the accuracy and completeness of your perceptions, to look for more supporting evidence before deciding a perception is indeed true, and to avoid jumping to conclusions.
Man is not disturbed by events,
but by the view he takes of them.
EPICTETUS |
PERCEPTION AND STRESS
In this section, we enter the domain of the stress response. Your perception of a given stressor is the first step in this response. While some events, such as the death of a loved one, are almost universally perceived to be stressful, most of the stressors that occur in daily life vary in their stress impact depending upon how you perceive them. Can't find the book you need in the library? On a scale of I to 10, how stressful is this? On a bad day it may be at least an 8, or even the proverbial straw that breaks the camel's back. On a good day you might give it a 1, shrug it off, and look for a different source. What happened the last time you spilled your drink all over the table? Did you perceive it to be something awful that should never happen, rant and rave, and get bent out of shape? Or did you remember that these things happen in the best of families, sigh, wipe up the mess, and soon forget it ever happened?
Take a look at the stress log you kept for Chapter 4. How did your perceptions affect your stress response? Were any stressors blown out of proportion? Were any created by a misunderstanding? Did you ever consciously adjust your perceptions to feel better and cope more effectively with stress? We attribute stress to particular situations and events. We say "That made me angry." "It scared me to death." The implication is that our feelings are directly caused by stressors. In the Student Stress example on the next page, Mark might think that the students whispering in the hallway caused his irritation, frustration, and anger. But in truth, Mark's perception of that stressor is the important link between the stressor and his stress response. As psychologist Paul Woods puts it, "A flat tire does not upset your stomach" (Woods, 1987). It is the perception that a flat tire is a problem that upsets your stomach. Adam's perception of the late night conversation did not trigger a full-blown stress response. By perceiving the situation in a less threatening way, he cut the connection. The whispering students became a minor source of irritation, easily dealt with. In fact, as Adam remembered his own whispered conversations in late night hallways, the situation even had some pleasant associations for him.
STUDENT STRESS |
CLASSMATES' PERCEPTIONS
Mark is studying in his room when he becomes aware of voices whispering in the hall. It is almost midnight, and he is upset about a problem set he is working on that is due first thing in the morning. His irritation rises as he focuses on the voices. "They should go talk somewhere else, not right outside my door! It's after quiet hours. I should report them to the residential supervisor. Here I am trying to get my work done, but how can I with all the distractions in this place. It's no wonder I am flunking out of school. I can't get any rest and this stupid professor doesn't realize I have three other courses to do assignments for. I'll never get it all done." As Mark's thoughts race out of control, so do his emotions. Irritation turns to frustration and anger, and a fullblown negative stress response ensues. Adam is Mark's classmate and is also having a midnight encounter with the same problem set. Let's say his room is just across the hall and that he hears the same voices whispering. Momentarily irritated, Adam realizes he has participated in late night hallway conversations from time to time himself. "Well, at least they are whispering and trying not to bother anyone. Their roommates are probably already asleep, so they went into the hall to talk. It's nice to know I am not the only one who is still awake around here!" Adam calmly asks the students if they can talk somewhere else. They head downstairs to the common room, and Adam turns his attention back to his assignment. His rational thinking has calmed his momentary irritation and he is back to his initial focus, free from the distractions of an inappropriate stress response. |
PERCEPTION AND STRESS RESISTANCE
Your perception of a stressor determines not only whether a stress response will result but also whether that stress response will be harmful to your health. Remember from Chapter 2 that if you perceive a stressor as something over which you have no control and believe it will probably have negative consequences, your stress response is likely to be physiologically more harmful than a stress response that gears you up for a positive challenge (Dienstbier, 1991; Vogel, 1985). As you evaluate, or appraise, a potential stressor, your thoughts, feelings, and even your physical stress response interact with one another. Negative thoughts cause painful emotions that cause tight muscles that cause more negative thoughts, painful emotions, and more physical discomfort. This cycle can lead to a Pandora's box of stress-related physical and psychological symptoms (Davis, Eshelman, & McKay, 1995; Jacobsen & Butler, 1996; Kabat-Zinn, 1990).
The way you appraise potential stressors and perceive reality determine to a large extent how happy you are. Remember from Chapter 11 that objective life circumstances have very little to do with subjective well-being (Diener & Diener, 1996; Lykken & Tellegen, 1996; Zika & Chamberlain, 1987). Rather, it is largely your point of view, the way in which you perceive the world and your place in it, that creates your degree of satisfaction. If you perceive yourself to be about where you should be, you will tend to feel satisfied. If you long to be somewhere or someone else, you will feel dissatisfied.
Your perception habits are also the basis of the attitude you reflect to people around you. The attitudes you project influence how others respond to you. If you continually find good reasons to feel angry and hostile, you will push others away, except perhaps other angry people. Over time you will find more unfairness and material for more anger and hostility.
REALITY CHECK: AVOID MAKING MOUNTAINS OUT OF MOLEHILLS
An inappropriate stress response often results from inaccurate perceptions regarding the nature of the stressor or your abilities to deal with it. The most common example of the creation of stress by inaccurate perceptions occurs so frequently that there is a cliche for it: making a mountain out of a molehill. Psychologist Albert Ellis has called it "awfulizing" or "catastrophizing" (Ellis, 1975). You awfulize when you tell yourself a situation is overwhelming or too much to bear. Mark's response to the hallway whispers is an example of awfulizing. He perceived that it was awful for the students to be whispering after quiet hours and that it would make him flunk out of school. How much of this was inherent in the stressor itself? Not much. But Mark's awfulizing turned the event into a source of serious stress.
Most of us awfulize from time to time. A low mark on an assignment means we will flunk the class, graduate (if we don't flunk out first) with a low grade point average, never get into the graduate program or career of our choice, alienate our parents, and spend the rest of our life flipping burgers at the fast food restaurant around the corner. Panic ensues. Usually, however, we correct our thinking momentarily and adopt a more pragmatic and rational perspective: the low mark means we don't understand some of the material and need to do some more studying or get some help. We discuss the problem with friends, maybe even the professor; often find out that half the class got low marks; laugh at our silly awfulizing thoughts; and devise a positive way to cope with the problem.
SELECTIVE ABSTRACTION: WHAT YOU SEEK YOU SHALL FIND
Danger arises when negative perception develops into a way of life. A negative outlook dramatically decreases stress resistance and often leads to feelings of chronic stress and the development of stress-related illness. Chronic depression, anxiety, and anger develop when a person tends to perceive events in ways that strengthen such feelings (Butterfield & LeClair, 1988; Rich & Bonner, 1987). Aaron Beck, a psychologist who has written extensively about cognitive therapy (using cognitive intervention techniques in a clinical psychotherapy setting), has referred to certain types of negative perception as selective abstraction (Beck, 1970). Selective abstraction means focusing on certain characteristics in the environment while overlooking others. Some refer to this kind of perception as tunnel vision (Davis et al., 1995). People who are chronically angry tend to focus on the unacceptable behavior of others and look for someone to blame when they find situations unfair or not as they "should be." Anxious people have a habit of anticipating problems and worrying that things will not go well. Depression can result from dwelling on what is not going well combined with feelings of hopelessness and helplessness.
A man is as happy as his mind
allows him to be.
ABRAHAM LINCOL |
HABITUAL PERCEPTION: YOUR AUTOMATIC PILOT
Cognitive intervention can help people improve their habitual way of viewing life. The first step is to become aware of habits of perception that may be causing stress by tuning in to your self- talk, also known as automatic thoughts. Both self-talk (Ellis, 1975) and automatic thoughts (Beck, 1970) refer to that commentary that runs in your head throughout the day. Some psychologists have called this commentary "mind chatter" (Gillespie & Bechtel, 1986). Mind chatter includes phrases, pictures, images, snatches of songs, and even complete sentences that you say to yourself. It runs the gamut from "I can't believe it's Thursday already!" and "The chocolate one looks good" to more emotionally laden images such as being buried in work, and phrases like "I can't handle this," "This job is killing me," and "I'll never make it through this day." Most of your self-talk is benign and is simply your interpretation of and reaction to what's going on. Stress- provoking thoughts are the ones to watch out for because they are associated with painful emotions and reduced stress resistance (Nutt-Williams & Hill, 1996). Automatic thoughts can be very destructive when they reinforce an interpretation of reality that fosters chronic anger, anxiety, or depression.
Reality is relative; we each have our own unique way of seeing the world, of interpreting and judging events around us. We may understand this on a rational level, but we still operate on the assumption that our perceptions are an accurate representation of reality and forget that we may not be perceiving the whole picture. Psychologist Aaron Beck coined the term automatic thoughts to emphasize that our mind chatter is perceived as automatic, as though it is simply a response to the environment (Davis et al., 1995). In other words, we forget they are even our thoughts and take these perceptions as reality itself.
Automatic thoughts can be hard to hear at first. They often appear as quick glimpses of phrases or images. Automatic thoughts connected with painful emotions often contain the words should, ought, or must, and usually reflect a judgment that something should be other than it is. The result: guilt, anger, disappointment. "I should spend more time studying." "The professor should be more understanding." "I should get paid more for this job." Destructive automatic thoughts tend to awfulize. The Tuning In exercise on the next page helps you see this.
STRESS AND YOU |
TUNING IN: CONNECTING EVENTS AND EMOTIONS
Tuning in to your mind chatter gives you a way to examine the accuracy of your perceptions and helps you discover destructive automatic thoughts. While tuning in takes some practice, all it requires is simple self-observation. Try the following exercise the next time you experience an unpleasant emotion, or think back to an incident in the recent past and try to untangle the thoughts and feelings you experienced. First, describe the situation or event that triggered the stress (A). Next, try to describe the thoughts running through your mind in response to the stressor (B). Then describe your feelings and behavior-what you felt and did (Q. Sometimes you might find it easier to complete item B, your thoughts, after describing A and C. This exercise is based on Albert Ellis's A-B-C rational-emotive therapy model (Ellis, 1975). A. Describe the stressor that "caused" the unpleasant emotion:
B. Write down thoughts you had in response to this stressor:
C. Write down your feelings and behavior:
|
Automatic thoughts reflect your habitual way of viewing the world. You began learning to interpret reality when you were a baby from your family and caregivers, and later from friends, teachers, and other important people in your life. While your early learning to perceive reality may have happened in a rather random fashion, as an adult you have acquired a more rational outlook and you are able to perceive reality more clearly. Since automatic thoughts are learned, the good news is that they can change. You can identify and question harmful thoughts and replace them with more productive ones that improve the accuracy of your perception and increase your stress resistance. You can take your perception off "automatic pilot" and choose a more scenic and interesting route (Braiker, 1989; Mahoney, 1993).
TUNING IN TAKES PLENTY OF PRACTICE
The idea that reality is relative and that one's perceptions can be questioned is new to many students, and untangling the web of perception, reality, and emotion can be very difficult. In other words, don't worry if the Tuning In exercise is difficult for you. Here is an example to help you understand and apply the exercise in your own life.
During study period for final exams, Sandra invited her boyfriend Elliot over for dinner. Theirs was still a fairly new relationship, and Sandra was anxious that the evening be enjoyable. Unfortunately, Elliot was feeling overloaded with schoolwork, was regretting his acceptance of Sandra's dinner invitation, and felt he should really stay home and study. Sandra was a straight A student and the work seemed to be easy for her. Elliot felt she would never understand his worries. However, he did not want to hurt her feelings, so he came reluctantly to dinner, his mind preoccupied with his work. Sandra had spent the entire afternoon cleaning her apartment, shopping for groceries, and preparing dinner. She couldn't understand why Elliot seemed so distant and self-absorbed. When she asked if everything was OK, he muttered something about all the work he had to do before next Friday; to Sandra, however, it sounded like he was making excuses rather than discussing a real problem. Sandra was disappointed and hurt when Elliot left shortly after dinner to return to his studies. Here is how she filled out the ABC exercise:
A. Stressor. Elliot came to dinner. He was extremely distant and cold, and he left early. He said he had schoolwork to do. I put a lot of energy into making a nice evening for us and he had a bad time. I wanted us to feel close and have fun.
C. Feelings and behavior. I'm angry, sad, and worried. I feel rejected and unloved. Since Elliot was acting so withdrawn, I didn't want to share my feelings with him, so I withdrew too. I have worried about this all day.
At this point Sandra replayed the scene in her head and tried to capture her thoughts and pin down her perception of events.
B. Thoughts: Maybe he is getting tired of me. He doesn't like me. I'm losing him. I wish we felt close again. I must be doing something wrong. I must not be likable and attractive. Why do my relationships always end so quickly?
REWRITING THE SCRIPTWhat do you think? How would you feel if you were Sandra? Certainly her disappointment is understandable. But is she getting the whole picture? What would you have done and thought differently? In the second part of this exercise you practice cognitive restructuring. What you restructure is your cognition, or thinking; you revise your perception of the stressor, or your abilities and resources, and in doing so alter your feelings and behavior as well (Matheny, Aycock, Pugh, Curlette, & Cannella, 1986). See exercises on page 262.
COGNITIVE RESTRUCTURING FOR STUDENTS: EXAM SELF-TALKExams are a common source of stress for most students. A little nervousness before an exam is fine; that's eustress that gets you aroused for a peak performance and opens the doors of your mind so the muse can visit. But some students experience such extreme distress before and during exams that it interferes with their ability to complete the exam. They get flustered, develop blocks, forget material, and generally lose their ability to concentrate. Exam time is a perfect occasion for awfulizing. The pressure is on, and students may overreact if perfect answers are not immediately forthcoming. If you find yourself doing more poorly on exams than you should given the good preparation you have done, listen in on your exam self-talk.
EXERCISE |
REWRITING SANDRA'S SCRIPT
Review the description of Sandra and Elliot's evening together above. Here again is Sandra's description of what happened. A. Stressor: Elliot came to dinner. He was extremely distant and cold, and he left early. He said he had schoolwork to do. I put a lot of energy into making a nice evening for us and he had a bad time. I wanted us to feel close and have fun. B. Thoughts: Maybe he is getting tried of me. He doesn't like- me. I'm losing him. I wish we felt close again. I must be doing something wrong. I must be likable and attractive. Why do my relationships always end so quickly? C. Feelings and behavior.- I'm angry, sad, and worried. I feel rejected and unloved. Since Elliot was acting so withdrawn, I didn't want to share my feelings with him, so I withdrew too. I have worried about this all day. How would you rewrite Sandra's thoughts to make them more rational and positive? How might this change her feelings? B.Sandra's revised thoughts:
C. Sandra's revised feelings and behavior.
Here is how one student rewrote Sandra's script: B. Sandra's revised thoughts: Something sure was bothering Elliot. I wonder if it really was his schoolwork. Why couldn't he talk about it? He never discusses his schoolwork with me. I wish I had asked more questions instead of withdrawing and getting offended, but I was so disappointed. I like him a lot and I'm afraid he'll lose intrest in me. Maybe he'll feel more relaxed once exams are over. C. Revised feelings and behavior: Although still disappointed, Sandra feels less rejected and depressed. By temporarily letting go of Elliot, she will give him some breathing room. Sandra decides to pursue activities with other friends during exam week and invite Elliot over again when he has finished his exams. |
STRESS AND YOU |
PART
Two:
REVISING YOUR THOUGHTS AND FEELINGS
Someone else's imperfect thinking is much easier to revise than your own "
normal"
response. But try. Go back to the situation you described on page 260 and try rewriting
your script. You may need to rewrite the stressor in even more "realistic" terms as well,
trying to remove your irrational perceptions and describe only what really happened (de
Moor, 1988).
|
Some examples of negative self-talk are listed in the exercise on pages 264-265. See whether you can change them to more positive statements, and use these statements yourself the next time you are in an exam stress situation.
THOUGHT STOPPING
Some students find that a simple technique called thought stopping is helpful for stress- provoking, repetitive automatic thoughts. If you have identified certain negative thoughts that recur frequently, you might wish to try thought stopping. When you realize that you are slipping into an old familiar negative thought, simply say to yourself "STOP!" or "Stop this thought." Change the channel to a more positive station. You may be surprised at how much control you have over your thinking.
The
real voyage of discovery consists not in seeking new landscapes but in
having new eyes.
|
REACHING DEEPER: IRRATIONAL BELIEFS
You may have wondered, as you revised the fictitious thoughts in the exercises above, whether rewriting the script is just a Band-Aid job. The language sounds stilted and phony. It's textbook writing, not your own voice. Can rewriting the words really change your feelings? Yes. Maybe not right away. But simply replacing the negative words that lead to painful emotions with more positive and realistic words is a start, even if you don't quite yet believe what you are telling yourself (McKay, Davis, & Fanning, 1981; Steinmetz, Blankenship, Brown, Hall, & Miller, 1980). After a while, you start to believe these thoughts. Cognitive restructuring starts to feel more natural. It gets easier to reframe reality, to see events in a more positive way; you feel less threatened by demands. Your stress resistance is increasing.
As you observe your mind chatter, you will uncover patterns of automatic thoughts. Certain themes will emerge. For example, you may discover that you tend to put yourself down when things are not going well. Or perhaps you complain and think it is awful when you have to work hard. Thoughts that cause painful emotions often reflect underlying irrational beliefs (Ellis, 1975; Davis et al., 1995). An irrational belief is an unreasonable concept acquired from your upbringing or somewhere along the line. It is something you have assumed to be true but does in fact not really mesh with reality. Not all irrational beliefs cause stress. Those that do generally fall into two categories: (1) beliefs that the world or someone or something should be different from the way it, he, or she is, and (2) beliefs that one's perceptions are factual rather than subjective (Rorer, 1991). Irrational beliefs often reflect cultural stereotypes; they may be distortions of these stereotypes. For example, you may have absorbed the teaching that it is wrong to be selfish, that you should always put others first. Maybe your parents always put their needs on hold and kept their resentment bottled up; now you unconsciously do the same.
EXERCISE |
REWRITING EXAM SELF-TALK
The following are examples of exam awfulizing. The first three statements are thoughts that come while you are waiting to start the exam; the last three occur as you begin to write the answers. Imagine you are well prepared for the exam and revise the thoughts so that they are more realistic and positive. 1. Everyone else is talking about the material before the exam starts. There are so many things I don't know! I probably studied the wrong stuff! Everyone else is much better prepared than I am. I should have studied more for this. Revised:
2. 1 have to get a good grade on this exam. If I don't do well I might not get into
graduate school. My whole life will be ruined!
3. Exams are so stupid! Why should I memorize all this stuff? I'm just going to forget it
in a few weeks anyway. I hate this school.
4. Oh my God! This test is way too long! I'll never get through in time!
5. Oh no! I don't know the answer to the first question. Oh, what will I do? I know I'm
going to fail this exam.
6. Three essay questions! I hate essay questions. I never know what the teacher wants
on these.
Of course there are many ways to correct these statements. Your goal is to create self- talk that will encourage the mental sharpness required to do well on exams. That means eliminating awfulizing and focusing on the positive. Here are some of the revisions students have come up with: Exam Self-Talk 1. Everyone else is talking about the material before the exam starts. There are so many things I don't know! I probably studied the wrong stuff! Everyone else is much better prepared than I am. I should have studied more for this. Revised: Everyone else is talking about the material before the exam starts. It makes me nervous that some are mentioning details I didn't memorize. I did my best to study the right stuff. Anyway, I must make the best of it now and focus on how much I do know.
2. 1 have to get a good grade on this exam. If I don't do well I might not get into
graduate school. My whole life will be ruined! 3. Exams are so stupid! Why should I memorize all this stuff? I'm just going to forget it in a few weeks anyway. I hate this school. Revised: I wish I didn't have to take exams; they seem so pointless. Oh well, that's the way school is. I did learn a lot in this course and will give these questions my best shot. 4. Oh my God! This test is way too long! I'll never get through in time! Revised: This test has a lot of pages. Just in case I don't have time to complete the whole thing, I'd better start with the questions that get the most points and keep track of the time.
5. Oh no! I don't know the answer to the first question. Oh, what will I do? I know I'm
going to fail this exam.
6. Three essay questions! I hate essay questions. I never know what the teacher wants
on these.
|
When your irrational beliefs run up against reality, conflict results and you feel stressed. Consider perfectionists. If you believe everything you do must be perfect, you are sure to be disappointed. It is simply impossible to achieve perfection. If you believe less than perfect is equivalent to failure, you will be afraid to try anything new. Perfectionists often suffer from low self-esteem, since they feel worthless when they fail to achieve their impossible standards (Burns, 1980; Ferrari, Johnson, & McCown, 1995). Remember from Chapter 7 that fear of failure and other irrational beliefs are a common source of procrastination. The following is a list of common irrational beliefs.
Common Irrational BeliefsIt is an absolute necessity for an adult to have love and approval from peers, family, and friends.
You must be unfailingly competent and almost perfect in all you undertake.
Certain people are evil, wicked, and villainous, and should be punished.
It is horrible when people and things are not the way you would like them to be.
External events cause most human misery-people simply react as events trigger their emotions.
You should feel fear or anxiety about anything that is unknown, uncertain, or potentially dangerous.
It is easier to avoid than to face difficulties and responsibilities.
The past has a lot to do with determining the present.
Happiness can be achieved by inaction, passivity, and endless leisure.
You are helpless and have no control over what you experience or feel.
People are fragile and should never be hurt.
Good relationships are based on mutual sacrifice and a focus on giving.
If you don't go to great lengths to please others, they will abandon or reject you.
When people disapprove of you, it invariably means you are wrong or bad.
Happiness, pleasure, and fulfillment can only occur in the presence of others, and being alone is horrible.
There is a perfect love, a perfect relationship.
You shouldn't have to feel pain; you are entitled to a good life.
Your worth as a person depends on how much you achieve and produce.
Anger is automatically bad and destructive.
It is bad or wrong to be selfish. (Davis, Eshelman, & McKay, 1995. Reprinted with permission by New Harbinger Publications, Oakland, CA 94609)
The mistaken assumptions listed in Chapter 8 are additional examples of irrational beliefs that lead to nonassertive or aggressive behavior, poor communication, and stress.
Do any strike a chord for you? Maybe you have some that are not listed here. Remember, you are concerned here with beliefs that increase feelings of stress and may be associated with automatic thoughts. You may never have verbalized these thoughts before, but some of these irrational beliefs may be subconscious guiding forces. Many studies have documented the link between irrational beliefs and feelings of stress (Bonner & Rich, 1991; Butterfield & LeClair, 1988; Hart, Turner, Hittner, Cardozo, & Paras, 1991; Rich & Bonner, 1987; Zingle & Anderson, 1990). People with more irrational beliefs see the glass as half empty, believing it should be full. They are more likely to appraise daily hassles as more stressful than do people with fewer irrational beliefs (Lazarus, 1991; Vestre & Burnis, 1987). People with irrational beliefs experience life in general as more stressful and have more negative emotions. Let's look at an example of how irrational beliefs lead to distorted perception and automatic thoughts that in turn trigger painful emotions and poor coping behavior.
STUDENT STRESS |
ANNA'S IRRATIONAL BELIEFS
Anna and Justin have lived together for almost two years. Both attend college, have part- time jobs, and share household duties. It's Friday afternoon, and Anna is tired. She is looking forward to a quiet evening at home, alone with Justin. On her way home, she stops at the grocery store and picks up some food to make one of the easy meals Justin likes best. She imagines the two of them going over events of the day and planning weekend activities, maybe reading for a while in the evening before an early bedtime. When she arrives home, she is very disappointed to find that a friend of Justin's has just stopped by unannounced for a visit. David lives over an hour away so he and Justin do not often have a chance to get together. Although Anna usually enjoys seeing David, she heaves a heavy sigh as she realizes that the evening is going to take a different direction from the one she had planned. After greeting David and Justin, Anna hurries to the kitchen to unpack the groceries. She starts clenching her teeth as she thinks to herself "Why tonight? I have absolutely no energy, but now I have to cook dinner and clean up after three of us. I've got to be cheerful and entertaining when all I feel like doing is going to bed. David should know better than to stop by unannounced when we are so busy. He should know I'm tired on Friday night. And now this visit is going to give me a headache." |
What's wrong with this picture? Take a look at Anna's self-talk. What are some of the irrational beliefs that seem to be causing stress for her? Anna is first of all distressed that things are not as they should be; it is horrible that things are not as she would like them to be. Instead of switching to a more positive gear, Anna continues to feel distressed as she focuses on how things should be but aren't. She also seems to feel that it is her job to step into the role of perfect hostess-that she must be entertaining and cheerful and shoulder the responsibility for cooking and cleaning up. Perhaps she is playing out some hostess stereotype, grudgingly doing her duty while resenting the burden of it all. And just to prove to herself that she has a right to be annoyed, she gives herself a headache.
Fortunately, Anna is taking a stress management class, and before her jaw tension develops into an uncontrollable pounding tension headache, she takes a deep breath and examines her self- talk. "Wait a minute," she says. "Let's reframe this picture. David's visit is not giving me a headache. I am giving myself this headache by focusing on my disappointment. Let's replay this scene and find a more positive option." Anna takes a problem-solving approach and realizes that her irrational beliefs had dictated an option she would not enjoy: playing cheerful hostess, waiting on Justin and David. Remember from Chapter 5 that the most important part of solving problems is a positive problem orientation and a creative mind. Irrational beliefs limit your ability to see problems and your options clearly. Revise Anna's thinking in the following exercise.
EXERCISE |
REWRITING ANNA'S SCRIPT
Revise Anna's self-talk to reflect more rational thinking and help her find a better way to solve her problem and cope with the stressor. Anna's new self-talk:
Anna's new feelings and behavior.
One student rewrote Anna's evening like this: Anna's new self-talk: Well, there goes my quiet evening with Justin. What should we do now? I'm too tired to cook dinner and clean up.I'll see if they will help me with dinner and clean up, but they probably want to sit around and talk about motorcycles. I know! Let's order a pizza; then nobody has to cook or clean. Anna's new feelings and behavior: Without the burden of disappointment, Anna is able to enjoy the evening with Justin and David. They all chip in for a pizza and share the clean-up chores. |
CHALLENGING IRRATIONAL BELIEFS
When you are rewriting your self-talk script, it is also a good idea to try to uncover the underlying irrational beliefs that may have led you astray. Anna tries to write the irrational belief that was driving her in the wrong direction:
Irrational belief: It is the girlfriend's job to be the perfect, cheerful hostess when her boyfriend's friends drop in. She must not admit she is tired or ask for help. A good girlfriend will pull together a delicious home-cooked meal on the spur of the moment, set a beautiful table, clean up all the dishes, and make the whole production look easy and effortless.
Once the irrational belief is pulled out of the psychic darkness, turned into a sentence or paragraph, and put down on paper, it may start to look a little silly in the light of day. The next step is to examine the belief with your rational mind. Ask yourself the following questions (Davis et al., 1995):
Is there any reason to think this belief is true?
What evidence suggests this belief might not be true?
What is the worst thing that could happen to me if I reject this belief?
What good things might happen if I reject this belief?
After you have examined the validity and consequences of the irrational belief, you can create a new belief to take the place of the irrational belief. Let's see how Anna followed this process.
Is there any reason to think this belief is true?
Well, my mother was always a good hostess and made people feel welcome in our
home. I think it is nice to make friends feel welcome.
What evidence suggests this belief might not be true?
But I guess it is not necessarily true that I have to put on the perfect hostess act to
make friends feel welcome in our home. I don't think it is really my 'Job" to magically
pull together a meal, do all the cleanup, and make the whole thing look effortless.
Anyway, it's not possible, especially on a Friday night after a long week of school and
work!
What is the worst thing that could happen to me if I reject this belief?.
Justin won't love me as much because I won't be the perfect girlfriend. Oops, this
sounds like another irrational belief. What could really happen ... I think it would be
worse to play the martyred girlfriend! If I don't play the perfect hostess, well, I might feel
like a failure.
What good things might happen if I reject this belief?
I won't mind having people visit. I'll enjoy Justin and our friends more. Justin won't
assume I can always play the perfect hostess-he'll get a better sense of who I really am.
He might as well find out now! We will work out ways to have friends over that don't
mean I do all the work and then feel resentful or get tension headaches.
Now Anna writes a new belief to take the place of her old irrational one. Compare the two.
Irrational belief: It is the girlfriend's job to be the perfect, cheerful hostess when her boyfriend's friends drop in. She must not admit she is tired or ask for help. A good girlfriend will pull together a delicious home-cooked meal on the spur of the moment, set a beautiful table, clean up all the dishes, and make the whole production look easy and effortless.
New belief: Justin and I want our friends to feel welcome in our home. A good girlfriend takes care of herself and her needs, as well as anticipating what will help everyone have fun together. People can get together and have fun even without a "perfect hostess" present!
Questioning and changing your irrational beliefs can lead to a remarkable increase in your stress resistance (Matheny et al., 1986; Woods, 1991). If you use the Tuning In exercise on page 260 to examine at least one stressful event every day and then question the irrational beliefs behind it, you will probably experience a reduction in stress symptoms in about two or three weeks (Davis et al., 1995).
Students sometimes worry that reframing events in a more positive fashion is artificial and phony. Some agree with Anna that David should call first. A few think Anna should let the men know that she is angry and make David go home. Some students feel that flexibility means compromising your beliefs and principles. We argue here that flexibility and compromise are essential for increasing your stress resistance. We also recommend choosing your battles; some principles should not be compromised. But a friend dropping in unannounced? Anna's initial disappointment is understandable, but she will only make herself miserable if she is unable to adjust her attitude. By all means let David know you would appreciate a call ahead next time. But given that David is going to stay for the evening, Anna needs to make the best of the situation.
Cognitive restructuring should not turn into repression. Cognitive restructuring begins with acknowledging your thoughts and feelings, not denying them, but then examining them for irrational and stress-inducing content. Anna would not change her self-talk to say, "Fantastic! I am so happy to spend the evening with Justin and David! I will happily cook them dinner and play the gracious hostess! Aren't we lucky David stopped by!" At its best, cognitive restructuring is really self-observation that questions and subsequently short-circuits stress- producing beliefs and self-talk.
OPTIMISM AND STRESS RESISTANCE: WHAT YOU SEE Is WHAT You GET
So far we have discussed revising self-talk and underlying beliefs to bring them more into line with reality. But stress resistance improves even more when you can take the process one step further and use the cognitive restructuring process to create some rose-colored glasses with which to view the world. Studies have shown that stress-resistant people consciously develop the habit of perceiving potential stressors in ways that give life meaning and give them a sense of control (Ornstein, & Sobel, 1989). They look for reasons to be happy and satisfied with life, imperfect as it is.
In some ways, the development of stress resistance is like the quest for happiness. What makes people happy? Money? Many rich people are miserably depressed. Good looks? Plenty of suicidal models. Getting a good job? Look at all the stressed-out "success stories." No, objective life circumstances do not define happiness. Perception does.
Happy people are optimists. They see themselves as doing OK making the best of what they've got. Although they may have lofty goals, they find their progress toward their goals acceptable. Instead of bemoaning what is wrong with the world, they focus on what is right. They expect good things to happen to them, and this view makes them open to opportunity. When misfortune strikes, as it does in everyone's life, optimists recover more quickly because they find lessons in adversity that contribute to life's meaning. Remember from Chapter 5 that one of the most effective coping methods for situations that can't be changed is positive reappraisal (Lazarus, 1991). Stress-resistant people are able to see demands as challenges and to gather strength from their ability to see the cloud's silver lining. just as selective abstraction can reinforce depression, so can it sustain happiness. One student told us she fosters her optimistic attitude by doing the following before going to bed: She asks herself three questions: What did I learn today? What was the nicest thing that happened today? What was the funniest thing that happened today? She controls her outlook by controlling her focus.
Consider now the irrational beliefs that may be causing stress for you. Can you think of a situation in which your irrational beliefs got you into trouble? Can you find a link between irrational beliefs and negative self-talk in your own life? Try rewriting the irrational beliefs to reflect a more realistic and positive outlook. For example: Irrational
belief:
It is
an absolute necessity for an adult to have love and approval from
peers, family, and friends. Revised: I want my peers, family, and friends to love me and approve of the things I do, but I realize that I can't always please everyone all the time. I will do my best, do what I feel in my heart is right, and accept the fact that not everyone will always agree with me. Irrational belief: You must be unfailingly competent and almost perfect in all you undertake. Revised: I will try to do my best, and learn from my mistakes. Now you try it: Irrational belief:
Revised:
Irrational belief:
Revised:
|
Questioning your irrational beliefs improves communication skills and increases stress resistance.
If you look for injustice and horror, you can certainly find it. just turn on the evening news. War, famine, disease, and death are all around. Life is not fair. Every person experiences unwanted events such as illness, rejection, loss; things are often not the way "we want them to be." When we respond to stressors, whether major life events or daily hassles, with the perception "I can't stand it.... It shouldn't be.... It isn't fair," we are denying reality. Stress resistance (wisdom, too) begins with an acceptance that life has its share of problems. While we will do everything we can to solve the problems and cope effectively with the stressors that come our way, many of these problems cannot be changed. Sometimes the only thing we can change is our attitude, our point of view (Chapman, 1987). We can change ourselves so that we are more compassionate and loving toward ourselves and others. We can emphasize the positive aspects of our lives. We can look for meaning, beauty, love, and peace, and appreciate them when we find them (Barber, 1984). We can use our sense of humor to decrease anxiety. And maybe, with our courage and ability to weather the storms of stress, just maybe, we can even change the world.
ACTION PLAN |
USING
COGNITIVE INTERVENTION TO
REDUCE
STRESS
Take some time to think about the roles your self-talk, irrational beliefs, general attitude, and outlook play in your stress cycle. Begin by describing what you are already doing well; then describe two changes you would like to make to reduce self-created stress. Describe some realistic steps that would help you make these changes.
|
STUDENT STRESS |
MICHAEL'S
ACTION PLAN
Michael was in his fifth year of college, having changed majors midstream and failed two courses. An average student, he worked hard and organized his time well, but he got mostly Cs in his courses. He hoped to graduate at the end of the year. Now he had a job search on top of his course load. "This job search alone is worth three credits," he often thought to himself. His academic struggles over the past few years had had a significant impact on his self-confidence, and he was very worried about finding a good job. He found himself saying, "You can't get a job without experience and you can't get experience without a job. What am I going to do? Who's going to want a C student?" As spring approached, he spent more and more time worrying until he felt like the unemployment cloud was hanging over him most of the time. Worried about his worrying, Michael enrolled in a stress management course. The material on the roll of perception in the stress cycle really hit home for him. "Mountains out of molehills-that's my specialty. I am creating my own stress by worrying about things too much." As Michael tuned into his self-talk, he found it full of anxiety about the future and statements reinforcing low self-esteem. "I feel like I have no control, and that makes me nervous," Michael concluded. "I think my worrying is an attempt to gain some control, but it doesn't work. It just makes things worse. Three irrational beliefs stood out as seeming rational to Michael. He had always strived to do things well (trying to be almost perfect), experienced anxiety about the unknown, and felt that his worth depended upon how much he achieved and produced. "No wonder this job search is driving me crazy!" he thought. "I value achievement and production and fear the unknown." Here is how Michael completed his action plan: 1 . Ways in which my self-talk and outlook are already increasing my stress resistance:I have a good sense of humor can even laugh at myself. I think I am good at tuning into my self-talk and can be honestly critical of my thoughts. 2. Changes
that would improve my stress resistance: 3.
Action steps that will help me achieve Goal 1: 2. Work with a career counselor to get some help with my job search.
4.
Action steps that will help me achieve Goal 2: 2. Use thought stopping when I catch myself worrying. 3. Replace worrying with positive thoughts like "I'm doing my best. Things will work out fine." 4. Dad always says "Trust the universe." |
SUMMARY
Perception is the link between stressors and your stress response. You can reduce feelings of stress by changing the way you appraise potential stressors and evaluate your abilities to cope effectively with them.
Cognitive intervention means changing your stress response by changing the way you think about stress and stressors.
While some events are almost universally perceived to be stressful, most of the stressors that occur in daily life vary in their stress impact, depending upon how you perceive them.
Your perception of a stressor determines not only whether a stress response will result but also whether that stress response will be harmful to your health. For example, if you perceive a stressor as something over which you have no control and believe it will probably have negative consequences, your stress response is likely to be more harmful physiologically than a stress response that gears you up for a positive challenge.
The way you appraise potential stressors and perceive reality determine to a large extent how happy you are.
"Awfulizing" or "catastrophizing" means perceiving a stressor to be much worse than it really is.
A negative outlook dramatically decreases stress resistance and often leads to feelings of chronic stress and the development of stress-related illness.
Selective abstraction means focusing on certain characteristics in the environment while overlooking others.
The terms self-talk, automatic thoughts, and mind chatter refer to the commentary that runs in your mind throughout the day. They include phrases, ideas, stories, pictures, images, snatches of songs, and so forth. People perceive their automatic thoughts as an accurate representation of reality.
Automatic thoughts that are connected with painful emotions often contain the words should, ought, or must and usually reflect a judgment that something should be other than it is.
Cognitive intervention techniques are based on the notion that you can identify and question harmful thoughts and stop them or replace them with more productive ones.
Thought stopping helps interrupt stress-provoking, repetitive automatic thoughts. When you become aware of a negative thought, simply say to yourself "STOP!" or "Stop this thought."
Irrational beliefs are unreasonable concepts that you hold to be true but in fact do not mesh with reality. Irrational beliefs that cause stress usually hold that (1) the world or someone or something should be different from the way it, he, or she is, or (2) one's perceptions are factual rather than subjective. They often reflect cultural stereotypes or may be distortions of these stereotypes.
Challenging and changing irrational beliefs can reduce negative self-talk and increase stress resistance.
Stress-resistant people consciously cultivate the habit of perceiving potential stressors in ways that give life meaning and themselves a sense of control. Cognitive restructuring techniques can be used to cultivate an optimistic outlook.
Banken, JA, and CH Mahone. Brief cognitive behavior therapy in an undergraduate pilot student: A case report. Aviation, Space, and Environmental Medicine 62: 1078-1080, 1991.
Barber, TX. Hypnosis, deep relaxation, and active relaxation: Data, theory, and clinical applications. RL Woolfolk and PM Lehrer (eds). Principles and Practice of Stress Management, New York: Guilford Press, 1984.
Beck, AT. Cognitive therapy: Nature and -relation to behavior therapy. Behavior Therapy 1: 184- 200,1970.
Bonner, RL, and AR
Rich. Predicting vulnerability to hopelessness: A longitudinal analysis. The
Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease 179: 29-32, 199 1.
Braiker, HB. The power of self-talk. Psychology Today, Dec 1989, pp
23-27.
Burns, DD. The perfectionist's script for self-defeat.
Psychology Today, Nov
1980, pp 34-46+.
Butterfield, PS, and S LeClair. Cognitive characteristics of bulimic and drug-abusing women. Addictive Behaviors 13: 131-138, 1988.
Castonguay, LG, MR Goldfried, S Wiser, PJ Raue, and AM Hayes. Predicting the effect of cognitive therapy for depression: A study of unique and common factors. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 64: 497-504, 1996.
Chang, EC. Cultural
differences in optimism, pessimism, and coping: Predictors of subsequent
adjustment in Asian American and Caucasian American college students. journal
of Counseling Psychology 43: 113-123, 1996.
Chapman, EN. Attitude: Your Most Priceless Possession. Los Altos, CA:
Crisp Publications, 1987.
Cheung, S-K. Cognitive-behaviour therapy for marital conflict: Refining the concept of attribution. Journal of Family Therapy 18: 183-203, 1996.
Craske, MG, E Maidenberg, and A Bystritsky. Brief cognitive-behavioral versus nondirective therapy for panic disorder. Journal of Behavioral Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry 26: 113-120,1995.
Davis, M, ER Eshelman, and M McKay. The Relaxation and Stress Reduction Workbook. Oakland, CA: New Harbinger Publications, 1995.
Deffenbacher, JL, RS Lynch, ER Oetting, and CC Kemper. Anger reduction in early adolescents. Journal of Counseling Psychology 43: 149-157, 1996.
de Moor, W. A
Rational-Emotive "A-B-C" model of emotional disturbances: A stress
model. Psvchotherapy in Private Practice 6: 21-33, 1988.
Diener, E, and C Diener. Most people are happy. Psychological Science 7:
181-185, 1996.
Dienstbier, RA.
Behavioral correlates of sympathoadrenal reactivity: The toughness model. Medicine
and Science in Sports and Exercise 23: 846-852, 1991.
Ellis, A. A New Guide to Rational Living. North Hollywood, CA:
Wilshire Books, 1975.
Epstein, N, DH Baucom, and LA Rankin. Treatment of marital conflict: A cognitive-behavioral approach. Clinical Psychology Review 13: 45-57, 1993.
Ferrari, JR, JLJohnson, and WG McCown. Procrastination and Task Avoidance. New York: Plenum Press, 1995.
Forman, SG.Rational-Emotive Therapy: Contributions to teacher stress management. School Psychology Review 19: 315-321, 1990.
Gidron, Y, and K
Davidson. Development and preliminary testing of a brief intervention for
modifying CHD-predictive hostility components. Journal of Behavioral
Medicine 19: 203-220,1996.
Gillespie, PR, and L Bechtel. Less Stress in 30 Days. New York: New
American Library, 1986.
Hart, KE, SH Turner, JB Hittner, SR Cardozo, and KC Paras. Life stress and anger: Moderating effects of Type A irrational beliefs. Personality and Individual Differences 12: 557-560,1991.
Hellman, CJC, M Budd, J Borysenko, DC McClelland, and H Benson. A study of the effectiveness of two group behavioral medicine interventions for patients with psychosomatic complaints. Behavioral Medicine 16: 165-173, 1990.
Hillenberg,JB, and FL Collins. The contribution of progressive relaxation and cognitive coping training in stress management programs. The Behavior Therapist 9: 147-149, 1986.
Jacobsen, PB, and
RW Butler. Relation of cognitive coping and catastrophizing to acute pain
and analgesic use following breast cancer surgery. Journal of Behavioral
Medicine 19: 17-29,1996.
Kabat-Zinn, J.
Full-catastrophe Living. New York: Dell
Publishing, 1990.
Lazarus, RS. Progress on a cognitive-motivational-relationaI theory of emotion. American Psychologist 46: 819-834, 1991.
Lee, F, M Hallahan, and T Herzog. Explaining real-life events: How culture and domain shape attributions. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 22: 732-741, 1996.
Lykken, D, and A Tellegen. Happiness is a stochastic phenomenon. Psychological Science 7: 186- 189,1996.
Maes, S. Reducing emotional distress in chronic patients, a cognitive approach. Communication and Cognition 20: 261-276, 1987.
Mahoney, MJ. Theoretical developments in the cognitive psychotherapies. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 61: 187-193, 1993.
Matheny, KB, DW
Aycock, JL Pugh, WL Curlette, and KAS Cannella. Stress Coping: A qualitative
and quantitative synthesis with implications for treatment. The
Counseling Psychologist 14: 499-549, 1986.
McKay, M, M
Davis, and P Fanning. Thoughts and Feelings: The Art of Cognitive Stress
Intervention. Oakland, CA: New Harbinger Publications, 1981.
Nutt-Williams,
E, and CE Hill. The relationship between self-talk and therapy process
variables for novice therapists. Journal of Counseling Psychology 43:
170-177, 1996.
Ornstein, R, and D Sobel.
Healthy Pleasures. Reading, MA: Addison
Wesley, 1989.
Rich, AR, and RL Bonner. Interpersonal moderators of depression among college students. Journal of College Student Personnel 28: 337-342, 1987.
Rorer, LG. A modern epistemological basis for Rational-Emotive Theory. Psychotherapy in Private Practice 8: 153-157, 1991.
Steinmetz, J, J Blankenship, L Brown, D Hall, and G Miller. Managing Stress Before It Manages You. Palo Alto, CA: Bull Publishing Co., 1980.
Vestre, ND, and JJ Burnis. Irrational beliefs and the impact of stressful life events. Journal of Rational- Emotive Therapy 5: 183-188, 1987.
Vogel, WH. Coping, stress, stressors, and health consequences. Neuropsychobiology 13: 129- 135,1985.
Woods, PJ. Reductions in Type A behavior, anxiety, anger, and physical illness as related to changes in irrational beliefs: Results of a demonstration project in industry. Journal of Rational-Emotive Therapy 5: 213-237, 1987.
Woods, PJ. Do you really want to maintain that a flat tire can upset your stomach? Using the findings of the psychophysiology of stress to bolster the argument that people are not directly disturbed by events. Journal of Rational-Emotive Therapy 5: 149-161, 1991.
Zika, S, and K Chamberlain. Relation of hassles and personality to subjective well-being. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 53: 155-162, 1987.
Zingle, HW, and SC Anderson. Irrational beliefs and teacher stress. Canadian Journal of Education 15: 445-449, 1990.
Zionts, P. Coping with self-defeating personal feelings. Focus on Autistic Behavior 5: 1-13, 1990.