In working with Hispanic patients language can be such an obvious barrier, challenge, and point of identity that it can sometimes obscure other critical more subtle aspects of cross-cultural understanding. There are certain cultural nuances or unwritten rules that govern social interactions. These unstated rules can impact the way in which individuals perceive, seek, and receive services. These essential cultural aspects can involve interactions as simple as conversational gambits and spatial (physical space) relationships, along with larger institutional issues such as family visiting hours, patient education, and measuring individual responses to pain. Being aware and understanding the cultural context for these interactions can be a tremendous asset to you as a health care professional, and in your ability to deliver effective care. "We’re a touching people. If you’re more than a handshake distance from your customer or patient you’re too far," says a Mexican American pharmacist and state legislator who has conducted cultural proficiency trainings for her colleagues. "Touching, how you make eye contact, the subtle things all count," she explains. "Diet is another example. Back in the early 1980s I’d try and help my patients adjust their diet to their medications. But the American Diabetes Association at the time had nothing on the Latino diet. They had a mainstream diet plan, and a supplement on a Jewish diet, but nothing my Hispanic patients in their 60s and 70s could use. They weren’t about to start eating brussels sprouts and cod for the first time in their lives. One older woman I remember looked at the material and asked me - ‘¿Qué es un bagel?’ (What’s a bagel?)." Common cultural characteristics for Hispanics in the United States include: family, respeto or respect, personalismo, and confianza. This chapter will give a brief description of each these cultural concepts. It is important to note that there will always be individual variation from any cultural norm. La Familia A good starting place for any discussion of Hispanic culture is with la familia, the family. Traditionally, Hispanics include many people in their extended families, not only parents and siblings, but grandparents, aunts, uncles, cousins and compadres, close friends and godparents (padrinos) of the family’s children. When ill or injured, Hispanic people frequently consult with other family members and often ask them to come along to medical visits. Hispanic extended families and the support role they play for patients may run counter to certain institutional rules, such as hospital policies that limit patients to two visitors. In the interest of effective care, such policies may need to be reexamined to allow for more direct involvement of the supportive family network. Hispanic families also traditionally emphasize interdependence over independence, and cooperation over competition, and are therefore far more likely to be involved in the treatment and decision making process for a patient. This level of involvement may not always be possible. Migration and separation from family may stress the values of young immigrant workers or couples newly arrived in the United States. Similarly, teenagers who quickly acculturate to the United States and the manners of their peers may demand to be treated as individuals and show signs of typical adolescent conflict with their parents and other relatives who maintain traditional values and customs. Because such stresses to family functioning may have significant health implications, it is important for the health care provider to be aware of these issues. Respeto For Hispanics the intimate confines of extended families, close-knit Hispanic communities, and traditional networks are mediated by respeto (respect). Respeto dictates appropriate deferential behavior towards others based on age, sex, social position, economic status, and authority. Older adults expect respect from youngsters, women from men, men from women, adults from children, teachers from students, employers from employees, and so on. Health providers, by virtue of their healing abilities, education, and training are afforded a high level of respeto as authority figures. As a general rule Hispanic patients tend to look forward to what the health care provider has to say and will value their direction and services. One way some Hispanics show respect is to avoid eye contact with authority figures. This respectful behavior should not be misinterpreted as a sign of disinterest. At the same time the health care provider is expected to look directly at the patient, even when communicating through an interpreter. Respeto implies a mutual and reciprocal deference. The Hispanic adult patient expects the provider to treat him/her with returned respect and may terminate treatment if they perceive that that respect is not being shown. Along with good health care practices such as providing the patient with information about the examination, diagnosis, and treatment; listening to the patient’s’ concerns; and, taking their individual needs into consideration while planning treatment, there are some additional steps you as a health care provider can take to assure the respect of your Hispanic patients. • If you’re a younger provider, even though you will be awarded
respect as an • Even if you do not speak Spanish, greeting a patient with "Buenos
dias" (good • Encourage the asking of questions. Out of a sense of respeto (respect)
many Health providers, as authority figures, need to take seriously the responsibility and respeto conferred on them by many Hispanic patients. They need to explain all medical procedures and treatments thoroughly, and to ascertain through careful questioning whether the patient has fully understood the explanations and instructions he/she has received. Personalismo Hispanics tend to stress the importance of personalismo–personal rather than institutional relationships, which is why so many Hispanics continue to rely on community-based organizations and clinics for their primary care. Hispanics expect health providers to be warm, friendly, and personal, and to take an active interest in the patient’s life. For example a health provider, even one with a limited time schedule for patient visits, might greet Señora Díaz with, "Buenos Días, Señora Díaz. How are you doing today? How did your daughter’s graduation go?" Such a greeting implies personalismo, conveying to the patient that the provider is interested in her as a person and will help put the patient at ease before an exam or medical procedure. When asked in focus groups where they received their medical care, the majority of Hispanics responded by naming their personal health care provider rather than their HMO or other health care institution. Hispanic loyalty to the individual provider also has significant implications for continuity of care. If a health care professional leaves a health center for another in close proximity, their Hispanic patients are likely to follow him/her to the new setting. If the health professional leaves the area however, their Hispanic patients may frequently stop treatment, unless the provider has made introductions to the new health care provider and established a transitional relationship between them based on personalismo. Unfortunately, personalismo tends to conflict with the health system’s trend towards managed care and away from individualized practices and long-term provider/patient relationships. It is a loss many in the health care system are feeling. The Hispanic patient’s desire for closeness to their health care provider is more than the content of their verbal exchanges; it also has to do with physical space. When interacting with others Hispanics typically prefer being closer to each other in space than non-Hispanic whites do. When non-Hispanic providers place themselves at their customary two feet or more distance away from their Hispanic patients, they may be perceived as not only physically distant but wrongly be thought of as uninterested and detached. Such perceptions can be overcome by sitting closer, leaning forward, giving a comforting pat on the shoulder, or other gestures that indicate an interest in the patient. Confianza Overall, Hispanics tend to be highly attuned to others’ non-verbal messages. Non-Spanish speaking providers should be particularly sensitive to this tendency when establishing a relationship with patients who speak only Spanish. Over time, by respecting the patient’s culture and showing personal interest, a health care provider can expect to win their confianza (trust). When there is confianza Hispanics will value the time they spend talking with their health care providers and believe what they say because confianza means that the provider will have their best interests at heart. Unfortunately confianza is increasingly difficult to achieve these days due to the dramatic changes occurring in the health care system, i.e., long-term provider-patient relationships are less common, physicians and others are limited in the amount of time they can spend with each patient, and HMOs and other institutions reduce their coverage and treatment of the poor. And yet despite these and other obstacles, the provider who is able to establish a bond of trust, confianza, with his or her Hispanic patient will find a profound improvement in the quality of care-giving and willingness of the patient to take wellness and risk-reduction advice to heart. Having won confianza from your patients you may also find yourself coming to appreciate the Hispanic view of health. Remember that with confianza there is compliance. While today’s health care professionals work within the structures of mainstream medicine, providing separate physical and mental health care, Hispanic culture tends to view health from a more synergistic point of view. This view is expressed as the continuum of body, mind, and espíritu (spirit). Within the last century, health and illness have been approached through a variety of treatments, each with its own philosophical base. Some have been based on empirical science (mainstream medicine), some believe disorders linked to the musculoskeletal system can be corrected by physical manipulations (osteopathy), some developed treatments based on the belief that minute doses of drugs that mimic diseases can be used to treat diseases (homeopathy). Still other approaches continue to base states of health on a purely spiritual belief system (Christian Science). In addition there is an extensive practice of traditional medicine carried out by curanderas, espiritistas, or healers within the Hispanic community. In urbanized barrios this tradition has been carried on in part by Hispanic pharmacists, familiar with both traditional treatments like té de manzanilla (chamomile tea) as well as placing a strong value on the use of modern prescription medicines such as antibiotics. In recent years there has also been a dramatic increase of interest on the part of mainstream medicine in researching and identifying many of the healing properties and pharmaceutical potentials of traditional medicines. Webster’s New University Dictionary defines synergy as, "1. The action of two or more organisms to achieve an effect of which each is individually incapable." and "2. The theological doctrine that regeneration is effected by a combination of human will and divine grace." The Hispanic view of the mind, body, spirit continuum is a very synergistic one, but also quite practical. Combining respect for the benefits of mainstream medicine, tradition and traditional healing, along with a strong religious component from their daily lives (over 77% of Hispanics in the United States are Catholic), Hispanic patients may bring quite a broad definition of health to the clinical or diagnostic setting. Respecting and understanding this view can prove beneficial both in treating and communicating with the patient, as well as useful for all health care professionals .
Copyright The National Alliance for Hispanic Health
REFERENCES 1. American Board of Internal Medicine. 1998a. "Cultural
Competence: Addressing a 2. American Board of Internal Medicine. 1998b. "Societal Forces
Reshaping American 3. Ashing-Giwa, K. 1999. "Health Behavior Change Models and
Their Socio-Cultural 4. Ayanian, J. Z., S. Udvarhelyi, C. A. Gatsonis, C. L. Pashos, and
A. M. Epstein. 5. Baker, D. W., R. Hayes, and J. P. Fortier. 1998. "Interpreter
Use and Satisfaction 6. Brach, C., and I. Fraser. 2000. "Can Cultural Competency
Reduce Racial and 7. Carrasquillo, O., E. J. Orav, T. A. Brennan, and H. R. Burstin.
1999. "Impact of 8. Commonwealth Fund. 1995. National Comparative Survey of Minority
Health Care. 9. Cooper-Patrick, L., J. J. Gallo. J. J. Gonzales, H. T. Vu, N. R.
Powe, C. Nelson, 10. D’Avanzo, C. E. 1992. "Barriers to Health Care for
Vietnamese Refugees." Journal 11. David, R. A., and M. Rhee. 1998. "The Impact of Language as
a Barrier to 12. Derose, K. P., and D. W. Baker. 2000. "Limited English
Proficiency and Latinos’ 13. Enguidanos, E. R., and P. Rosen. 1997. "Language as a Factor
Affecting 14. Erwin, D. O., T. S. Spatz, R. C. Stotts, and J. A. Hollenberg.
1999. "Increasing 15. Facione, N. C. 1999. "Breast Cancer Screening in Relation to
Access to Health 16. Ferguson, J. A., M. Weinberger, G. R. Westmoreland, L. A. Mamlin,
D. S. Segar, 17. Fernandez, M. E., M. DeBor, M. J. Candreia, K. Wagner, and K. R.
Stewart. 1999. 18. Flaskerud, J. H., and G. Uman. 1993. "Directions for AIDS
Education for Hispanic 19. Fletcher, S. W., R. P. Harris, J. J. Gonzalez, D. Degnan, D. R.
Lannin, V. J. 20. Flores, G., and L. R. Vega. 1998. "Barriers to Health Care
Access for Latino 21. Frederick Schneiders Research. 1999. Perceptions of How Race
and Ethnic 22. Gordon, A. K. 1995. "Deterrents to Access and Service for
Blacks and Hispanics: 23. Guidry, J. J., and V. D. Walker. 1999. "Assessing Cultural
Sensitivity in Printed 24. Hampers, L. C., S. Cha, D. J. Gutglass, H. J. Binns, and S. E.
Krug. 1999. 25. Kaiser Family Foundation. 1999. Race, Ethnicity and Medical Care:
A Survey of 26. Kaplan, S. H., S. Greenfield, and J. Ware. 1989. "Assessing
the Effects of 27. Lannin, D. R., H. F. Mathews, J. Mitchell, M. S. Swanson, F. H.
Swanson, and 28. Lavizzo-Mourey, R., and E. R. Mackenzie. 1996. "Cultural
Competence: Essential 29. Lawson, W. B. 1996. "The Art and Science of the
Psychopharmacotherapy of 30. Manson, A. 1988. "Language Concordance as a Determinant of
Patient 31. McAlister, A. L., M. E. Fernandez-Esquer, A. G. Ramirez, F.
Trevino, K. J. Gallion, 32. Moffic, H. S., and J. D. Kinzie. 1996. "The History and
Future of Cross-Cultural 33. Mohrmann, C. C., E. A. Coleman, S. K. Coon, J. E. Lord, J. K.
Heard, M. J. 34. Morales, L. S., W. E. Cunningham, J. A. Brown, H. Liu, and R. D.
Hays. 1999. " 35. Ong, L. M. L., J. C. J. M. De Haes, A. M. Hoos, and F. B. Lammes.
1995. 36. Pachter, L. M. 1994. "Culture and Clinical Care: Folk
Illness Beliefs and Behaviors 37. Peterson, E. D., S. M. Wright, J. Daley, and G. E. Thibault.
1994. "Racial 38. Rathore, S. S., L. A. Lenert, K. P. Weinfurt, A. Tinoco, C. K.
Taleghani, W. 39. Sarver, J., and D. W. Baker. 2000. "Effect of Language
Barriers on Follow-up 40. Schulman, K. A., J. A. Berlin, W. Harless, J. F. Kerner, S.
Sistrunk, B. J. Gersh, R. 41. Sheifer, S.E., J. J. Escarce, and K. A. Schulman. 2000.
"Race and Sex Differences 42. Solis, J. M., G. Marks, M. Garcia, and D. Shelton. 1990.
"Acculturation, Access 43. Stein, J. A., S. A. Fox, and P. J. Murata. 1991. "The
Influence of Ethnicity, 44. Stewart, M., L. Meredith, J. B. Brown, and J. Galajda. 2000.
"The Influence of 45. Stewart, M. A. 1995. "Effective Physician-Patient
Communication and Health 46. Takeuchi, D. T., E. Uehara, and G. Maramba. 1999. "Cultural
Diversity and 47. Tocher, T. M., and E. Larson. 1998. "Quality of Diabetes
Care for Non-English 48.
Uba, L. 1992. "Cultural Barriers to Health Care for
Southeast Asian Refugees." 49. van Ryn, M., and J. Burke. 2000. "The Effect of Patient Race
and Socio - 50. Wagner, T. H., and S. Guendelman. 2000. "Healthcare
Utilization among 51. Weber, B. E., and B. M. Reilly. 1997. "Enhancing Mammography
Use in the Inner 52. Weissman, J. S., R. Stern, S. L. Fielding, and A. M. Epstein.
1991. "Delayed 53. Whittle, J., J. Conigliaro, C. B. Good, and M. Joswiak. 1997.
"Do Patient 54. Woloshin, S., L. M. Schwartz, S. J. Katz, and H. G. Welch. 1997.
"Is Language a 55. Wright, A. L., A. Naylor, R. Wester, M. Bauer, and E. Sutcliffe.
1997. "Using
|